Whoopi Goldberg’s 69th birthday celebration on November 13 became controversial after the comedian accused Staten Island’s iconic Holtermann’s Bakery of refusing her birthday order due to her political views. The claim, made on The View, quickly sparked debate and drew strong reactions from both supporters and critics of the bakery.

Image credits: Whoopi Goldberg
Whoopi’s Claim on The View
During a recent episode of The View, Goldberg alleged that the 145-year-old Holtermann’s Bakery had declined to fulfill her birthday order. “Perhaps they did not like my politics,” Goldberg speculated, expressing her disappointment over the perceived slight.

Image credits: people

Image credits: people
Goldberg reiterated her frustration in an Instagram video, in which she stated, “This isn’t just about me—it’s about something bigger. If this was intentional, it’s not okay.” The video garnered support from some fans but also faced backlash from others who questioned the validity of her accusations.
Staten Island Locals and Bakery Defenders Speak Out
Holtermann’s Bakery, a family-owned establishment beloved by Staten Island residents, has yet to issue an official statement regarding Goldberg’s remarks. However, locals have rallied to defend the bakery, describing Goldberg’s claims as unfounded and damaging.

Image credits: Holtermann’s Bakery
“This bakery has been serving our community for generations, and it’s never been about politics,” said one Staten Islander during an impromptu gathering outside the bakery. Social media platforms were flooded with similar sentiments, with many calling Goldberg’s accusations “ridiculous” and “out of touch.”

Image credits: Holtermann’s Bakery
Borough President Demands Apology
The controversy took a political turn when Staten Island Borough President Vito Fossella held a press conference outside Holtermann’s Bakery. Fossella strongly condemned Goldberg’s statements, calling them defamatory.

Image credits: Vito J. Fossella
“The people who defamed this cherished institution owe it an apology,” Fossella declared. He praised the bakery for its long-standing contributions to the community and emphasized that such accusations could unjustly harm its reputation.

Image credits: Vito J. Fossella
Mixed Reactions Online
Goldberg’s claims divided public opinion, with some fans supporting her for speaking out and others criticizing her for making unverified accusations.
- Supporters of Goldberg: Many applauded her for bringing attention to potential business bias. “If this was intentional, it’s a big issue,” one Twitter user wrote.
- Critics of Goldberg: Others argued that the incident was likely a misunderstanding. “This is a 145-year-old bakery we’re talking about, not a political campaign HQ,” one commenter said.
- Neutral Observers: Some questioned the situation, suggesting it may have been a mix-up. “Where’s the proof of intentional bias? Let’s not jump to conclusions,” another user noted.

Image credits: Whoopi Goldberg

Image credits: Holtermann’s Bakery
Birthday Celebration Despite Grievances
Despite the drama, Goldberg celebrated her 69th birthday surrounded by loved ones and her The View co-hosts. While the Holtermann’s Bakery incident overshadowed her milestone, fans and friends ensured she felt celebrated and cherished.

Image credits: Whoopi Goldberg
The feud between Whoopi Goldberg and Holtermann’s Bakery highlights the complexities of celebrity influence and community pride. While Goldberg’s claims have sparked a conversation about potential bias in businesses, Staten Island locals and leaders remain steadfast in defending the bakery’s integrity.

Image Credits: yahoo
As the debate continues, one question looms: Was this incident a misunderstanding, or does it point to deeper issues? Either way, the controversy serves as a reminder of how quickly words and perceptions can shape public opinion in today’s hyper-connected world.